United States Trade Representative (USTR) Katherine Tai gave what was billed as a major speech at CSIS outlining US trade policy on October 4. A careful review of China policy has been underway for months and Tai’s speech was to deliver the results of this study. At the end of her prepared remarks and a short round of questions, observers were left with few clues about the future trajectory of US policies and little detail beyond broad brush strokes already sketched over previous months. What was made clear is that US trade policy, in practice, is not likely to look substantially changed from paths pursued by the previous Trump administration. In fact, if Tai’s speech were read alongside similar policy statements made under the Trump team, it would be difficult to pick out who said what. First, Tai argued that China has failed to follow appropriate actions or adjust its bad behavior despite a long history of engagement. The approach used under the Trump administration, in particular the Phase 1 agreement, may not have been exactly the model she would have chosen (what model she might have thought more suitable was not discussed), but it remains in place. Tai did express distain for the term “Phase 1,” even as she essentially promised to follow it. Tariffs will continue to be imposed on Chinese imports, although the administration will restart the process of reviewing requests for exclusion. With limited details available on the process, however, it is unclear whether tariffs will be waived in large part, or only in limited circumstances. Nor was there any clarity on how long the process may take to conclude. Given the relatively limited time “left” on the Phase 1 agreement, even a short delay may deliver only modest benefits to US firms struggling to manage tariffs of up to 25% which have now been imposed, in some cases, for years.